Western Blot Protein Transfer Systems

One of the key steps in the western blot workflow is the transfer of proteins from the polyacrylamide gel after electrophoresis to the nitrocellulose or polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) membrane so that specific proteins can be detected using immune-detection techniques.

We have developed electrophoretic transfer systems for wet, semi-dry, and dry blotting methods. Use the table below to select the appropriate transfer method for your western blotting needs.

Transfer membranes  Transfer buffers

Which western blot transfer system is right for you?

Wet transfer Semi-dry transfer Dry transfer
Invitrogen Mini Blot Module
Mini Blot Module
Invitrogen XCell Blot Module
XCell II Blot Module
SureLock Tandem Midi Blot Module
SureLock Tandem Midi Blot Module
Invitrogen Power Blotter System
Power Blotter Systems
Invitrogen iBlot 2 Dry Blotting System
iBlot 2 Dry Blotting System
Capacity:
1 mini gel per blot module; 1–2 blot modules per tank
Capacity:
1 mini gel per blot module; 1–2 blot modules per tank
Capacity: 
1 midi gel per blot module; 1–2 blot modules per tank
Capacity:
1–4 mini or 1–2 midi gels
Capacity:
1–2 mini or 1 midi gel
Transfer time: 60 min Transfer time:
60–120 min
Transfer time: 
30 min
Transfer time:
5–10 min
Transfer time:
7 min
Blotting area:
9 x 9 cm
Blotting area:
9 x 9 cm
 Blotting area: 
9.2 x 14.4 cm
Blotting area:
10 x 18 cm or
21 x 22.5 cm
Blotting area:
8.5 x 13.5 cm
Blotting area: Transfer buffer volume:
200–400 mL
Transfer buffer volume:
1,000 mL
Transfer buffer volume:  
300 mL per blot module
Transfer buffer volume:
Pre-cut membranes & filters: 50–100 mL; 
Select transfer stacks: buffer not required
Transfer buffer volume:
Buffer not required
Power supply: External Power supply: External  Power supply: 
External
Power supply: Internal Power supply: Internal
Required equipment:
Mini Gel Tank: capacity for up to 2 Mini Blot Modules
Required equipment:
XCell SureLock Mini-Cell: capacity for up to 2 blot modules
Required equipment:
SureLock Tandem Midi Gel Tank: capacity for up to 2 blot modules
––– –––
Learn more Learn more Learn more Learn more Learn more

Comparison of western blot transfer methods

  Invitrogen wet transfer system, Mini Blot Module Invitrogen semi-dry system, Power Blotter Invitrogen dry transfer system, iBlot 2
  Wet transfer Semi-dry transfer Dry transfer
Setup Hands-on, requires preparing transfer buffer ~15–20 min ~5-10 min with Select stacks, ~10–15 min for pre-cut membranes and filters ~5 min
Cleanup Extensive clean-up after each use including hazardous methanol waste disposal Light clean-up required after each use Very minimal with extended used
Transfer time 30–120 min 7–10 min 7 min
Throughput +++ +++ +
Performance +++ ++ +++
Ease of use ++ +++ +++
Transfer buffer requirements Requires methanol Methanol-free transfer buffers or no buffer required with pre-assembled stacks No buffer required
Special considerations Cooling may be required for longer transfers Multiple systems can be utilized including Towbin buffers Requires pre-assembled transfer stacks

Comparison of wet, semi-dry and dry transfer methods

Efficient and reliable protein transfer from the gel to the blotting membrane is the cornerstone of a successful western detection experiment. Accuracy of results is dependent on the transfer efficiency of the western blotting method. Traditional wet transfer offers high efficiency, but at a cost of time and effort. Semi-dry blotting provides convenience and time savings, with flexibility to use multiple types of buffer systems or pre-assembled stacks that are buffer free. However, semi-dry transfer can have a lower efficiency of transfer of large molecular weight proteins (>300 kDa). Dry electroblotting offers both high quality transfer combined with speed as well as convenience since added buffers are not required for dry electroblotting.

Three major ways to transfer proteins from SDS-PAGE or native gels to nitrocellulose, PVDF or nylon membranes:

Wet tank electrotransfer

When performing a wet transfer, the gel is first equilibrated in transfer buffer. The gel is then placed in the “transfer sandwich” (filter paper-gel-membrane-filter paper), cushioned by pads and pressed together by a support grid. The supported gel sandwich is placed vertically in a tank between stainless steel/platinum wire electrodes and filled with transfer buffer.

Multiple gels may be electrotransferred in the standard field option, which is performed either at constant current (0.1 to 1 A) or voltage (5 to 30 V) from as little as 1 hour to overnight. Transfers are typically performed with an ice pack and at 4°C to mitigate the heat produced. A high field option exists for a single gel, which may bring transfer time down to as little as 30 minutes, but it requires the use of high voltage (up to 200 V) or high current (up to 1.6 A) and a cooling system to dissipate the tremendous heat produced.

Transfer efficiencies of 80–100% are achievable for proteins between 14–116 kDa. The transfer efficiency improves with increased transfer time. With increasing time, however, there is a risk of over-transfer (blew through) of the proteins through the membrane, especially for lower molecular weight (<30 kDa) proteins when using membranes with a larger pore size (0.45 µm).

Semi-dry electrotransfer

For semi-dry protein transfer, the transfer sandwich is placed horizontally between two plate electrodes in a semi-dry transfer apparatus. For this semi-dry transfer, it is very important that the gel is pre-equilibrated in transfer buffer. To maximize the current passing through the gel instead of around the gel, the amount of buffer available during transfer is limited to that contained in the sandwich, so it is helpful if the extra-thick filter paper (~3 mm thickness) and membrane are also sufficiently soaked in buffer. Likewise, it is key that the filter paper sheets and membrane are cut to the size of the gel.

One to four gels may be rapidly electroblotted to membranes. Methanol may be included in the transfer buffer, but other organic solvents, including aromatic hydrocarbons, chlorinated hydrocarbons and acetone, should not be used to avoid damage to the semi-dry blotter. Electrotransfer is performed either at constant current (0.1 up to ~0.4 A) or voltage (10 to 25 V) for 10 to 60 minutes. Methanol-free transfer buffers are recommended to reduce transfer time to 7 to 10 minutes. Transfer efficiencies of 60 to 80% may be achievable for proteins between 14 and 116 kDa, longer transfer times are required to transfer higher molecular weight proteins.

Dry electrotransfer

Dry electroblotting methods use a specialized transfer sandwich containing innovative components that eliminate use of traditional transfer buffers. A unique gel matrix (transfer stack) that incorporates buffer is used instead of buffer tanks or soaked filter papers. The high ionic density in the gel matrix enables rapid protein transfer. During blotting, the copper anode does not generate oxygen gas as a result of water electrolysis, reducing blot distortion. Conventional protein transfer techniques, including wet and semi-dry, use inert electrodes that generate oxygen. Typically, transfer time is reduced by the shortened distance between electrodes, high field strength and high current.

Which western blot transfer system is right for you?

Wet transfer Semi-dry transfer Dry transfer
Invitrogen Mini Blot Module
Mini Blot Module
Invitrogen XCell Blot Module
XCell II Blot Module
SureLock Tandem Midi Blot Module
SureLock Tandem Midi Blot Module
Invitrogen Power Blotter System
Power Blotter Systems
Invitrogen iBlot 2 Dry Blotting System
iBlot 2 Dry Blotting System
Capacity:
1 mini gel per blot module; 1–2 blot modules per tank
Capacity:
1 mini gel per blot module; 1–2 blot modules per tank
Capacity: 
1 midi gel per blot module; 1–2 blot modules per tank
Capacity:
1–4 mini or 1–2 midi gels
Capacity:
1–2 mini or 1 midi gel
Transfer time: 60 min Transfer time:
60–120 min
Transfer time: 
30 min
Transfer time:
5–10 min
Transfer time:
7 min
Blotting area:
9 x 9 cm
Blotting area:
9 x 9 cm
 Blotting area: 
9.2 x 14.4 cm
Blotting area:
10 x 18 cm or
21 x 22.5 cm
Blotting area:
8.5 x 13.5 cm
Blotting area: Transfer buffer volume:
200–400 mL
Transfer buffer volume:
1,000 mL
Transfer buffer volume:  
300 mL per blot module
Transfer buffer volume:
Pre-cut membranes & filters: 50–100 mL; 
Select transfer stacks: buffer not required
Transfer buffer volume:
Buffer not required
Power supply: External Power supply: External  Power supply: 
External
Power supply: Internal Power supply: Internal
Required equipment:
Mini Gel Tank: capacity for up to 2 Mini Blot Modules
Required equipment:
XCell SureLock Mini-Cell: capacity for up to 2 blot modules
Required equipment:
SureLock Tandem Midi Gel Tank: capacity for up to 2 blot modules
––– –––
Learn more Learn more Learn more Learn more Learn more

Comparison of western blot transfer methods

  Invitrogen wet transfer system, Mini Blot Module Invitrogen semi-dry system, Power Blotter Invitrogen dry transfer system, iBlot 2
  Wet transfer Semi-dry transfer Dry transfer
Setup Hands-on, requires preparing transfer buffer ~15–20 min ~5-10 min with Select stacks, ~10–15 min for pre-cut membranes and filters ~5 min
Cleanup Extensive clean-up after each use including hazardous methanol waste disposal Light clean-up required after each use Very minimal with extended used
Transfer time 30–120 min 7–10 min 7 min
Throughput +++ +++ +
Performance +++ ++ +++
Ease of use ++ +++ +++
Transfer buffer requirements Requires methanol Methanol-free transfer buffers or no buffer required with pre-assembled stacks No buffer required
Special considerations Cooling may be required for longer transfers Multiple systems can be utilized including Towbin buffers Requires pre-assembled transfer stacks

Comparison of wet, semi-dry and dry transfer methods

Efficient and reliable protein transfer from the gel to the blotting membrane is the cornerstone of a successful western detection experiment. Accuracy of results is dependent on the transfer efficiency of the western blotting method. Traditional wet transfer offers high efficiency, but at a cost of time and effort. Semi-dry blotting provides convenience and time savings, with flexibility to use multiple types of buffer systems or pre-assembled stacks that are buffer free. However, semi-dry transfer can have a lower efficiency of transfer of large molecular weight proteins (>300 kDa). Dry electroblotting offers both high quality transfer combined with speed as well as convenience since added buffers are not required for dry electroblotting.

Three major ways to transfer proteins from SDS-PAGE or native gels to nitrocellulose, PVDF or nylon membranes:

Wet tank electrotransfer

When performing a wet transfer, the gel is first equilibrated in transfer buffer. The gel is then placed in the “transfer sandwich” (filter paper-gel-membrane-filter paper), cushioned by pads and pressed together by a support grid. The supported gel sandwich is placed vertically in a tank between stainless steel/platinum wire electrodes and filled with transfer buffer.

Multiple gels may be electrotransferred in the standard field option, which is performed either at constant current (0.1 to 1 A) or voltage (5 to 30 V) from as little as 1 hour to overnight. Transfers are typically performed with an ice pack and at 4°C to mitigate the heat produced. A high field option exists for a single gel, which may bring transfer time down to as little as 30 minutes, but it requires the use of high voltage (up to 200 V) or high current (up to 1.6 A) and a cooling system to dissipate the tremendous heat produced.

Transfer efficiencies of 80–100% are achievable for proteins between 14–116 kDa. The transfer efficiency improves with increased transfer time. With increasing time, however, there is a risk of over-transfer (blew through) of the proteins through the membrane, especially for lower molecular weight (<30 kDa) proteins when using membranes with a larger pore size (0.45 µm).

Semi-dry electrotransfer

For semi-dry protein transfer, the transfer sandwich is placed horizontally between two plate electrodes in a semi-dry transfer apparatus. For this semi-dry transfer, it is very important that the gel is pre-equilibrated in transfer buffer. To maximize the current passing through the gel instead of around the gel, the amount of buffer available during transfer is limited to that contained in the sandwich, so it is helpful if the extra-thick filter paper (~3 mm thickness) and membrane are also sufficiently soaked in buffer. Likewise, it is key that the filter paper sheets and membrane are cut to the size of the gel.

One to four gels may be rapidly electroblotted to membranes. Methanol may be included in the transfer buffer, but other organic solvents, including aromatic hydrocarbons, chlorinated hydrocarbons and acetone, should not be used to avoid damage to the semi-dry blotter. Electrotransfer is performed either at constant current (0.1 up to ~0.4 A) or voltage (10 to 25 V) for 10 to 60 minutes. Methanol-free transfer buffers are recommended to reduce transfer time to 7 to 10 minutes. Transfer efficiencies of 60 to 80% may be achievable for proteins between 14 and 116 kDa, longer transfer times are required to transfer higher molecular weight proteins.

Dry electrotransfer

Dry electroblotting methods use a specialized transfer sandwich containing innovative components that eliminate use of traditional transfer buffers. A unique gel matrix (transfer stack) that incorporates buffer is used instead of buffer tanks or soaked filter papers. The high ionic density in the gel matrix enables rapid protein transfer. During blotting, the copper anode does not generate oxygen gas as a result of water electrolysis, reducing blot distortion. Conventional protein transfer techniques, including wet and semi-dry, use inert electrodes that generate oxygen. Typically, transfer time is reduced by the shortened distance between electrodes, high field strength and high current.

Resources

Western Blotting Overview Brochure